ScoliScore/C-GAAP Should Drive Clinical Lab Revs in 2013
By Brian Marckx, CFA
Q3 2012 RESULTS
Transgenomic (TBIO) reported financial results for Q3 ending September 30, 2012 on November 8th. Revenue fell just over 4% yoy and was well below our estimate due to relatively disappointing numbers from the Pharmacogenomics and Instruments/Diagnostics segments. While Clinical Lab revenue was dead-on with our $4.5 million estimate, the 10% yoy growth in this segment was more than offset by a very poor showing in Pharmacogenomics ($220k, -60% yoy) and Instruments ($3.2 million, -12% yoy).
As a reminder, Pharmacogenomics activity can be highly variable q-to-q, largely dependent on customer directives and not in direct control of TBIO which makes forecasting this line difficult on a short-term basis. Nonetheless Pharmacogenomics revenue in aggregate has disappointed over the first nine months of the year - which we think relates at least in part to longer than anticipated timelines (and potentially delays) of TBIO's phase III clinical trial customer(s). TBIO is still awaiting the green-light from a pharma customer to commence processing for a phase III trial - our model had assumed this work would have already commenced - we are now pushing this assumption and the related revenue back to 2013.
Relative to the Instruments/Diagnostics business, management noted that while they sold more instruments in the quarter compared to the year earlier period, revenue was significantly softer as the majority were sold through Menarini, their European distributor (at a lower average price point relative to the year earlier period which were mostly non-distributor sales). Going forward we continue to expect bioconsumables to be the major revenue driver of the Diagnostics business, particularly with the launch of several cancer marker kits using ICE COLD PCR which should begin to show a meaningful contribution in 2013.
The quarter did have some important positive highlights, namely the ScoliScore acquisition and new collaborations with ICE COLD PCR (with NYU and Univ of Nebraska). Management also noted that C-GAAP, TBIO's Plavix response test, has seen strong physician interest and was a substantial contributor to the 10% growth in Clinical Lab revenues. ScoliScore, as we noted in our 8/9/12 Investor Note (see below), looks like a very solid addition to TBIO's Clinical Lab business and one which we think will make a meaningful top and bottom line impact as early as next year.
The collaboration with NYU's Langone Medical Center involves the use of ICE COLD PCR in the detection of mutations in the blood related to non-small cell lung cancer and response to existing a new therapies. Similar to the collaboration with the MD Anderson Cancer Center (Univ of Texas), the NYU study will focus on circulating tumor cells (CTCs) and use TBIO's CTC capture ScreenCell devices. The collaboration with the University of Nebraska Medical Center involves the use of ICE COLD PCR in the early detection of pancreatic cancer and is being funded by a $100k NIH grant awarded to TBIO which was announced in August. The project could result in a diagnostic test for early stage pancreatic cancer which is almost always fatal if not caught early.
Q3 revenue was $7.9 million, down 4% y-o-y and $1.1 million (13%) less than our $9.0 million estimate. The difference came from a $555k variance ($220k A vs. $775k E) in Pharmacogenomics revenue and a $607k variance ($3.2 million A vs. $3.8 million E) in Instruments/Diagnostics with Clinical Lab revenue in-line with our $4.5 million estimate.
Similar to Q1 and Q2, GM came in well softer than our estimate. Q3 GM was 48% compared to our 55% estimate. Lower than expected revenue from Pharmacogenomics continues to impact GM due to the fixed laboratory costs - while this segment should be highly leverageable with growing revenue, margins will be almost non-existent at the ~$250k and lower revenue level (this quarter was $220k). Management also noted that they've made some investments related to their Clinical Lab segment to improve efficiencies in anticipation of increased sales of C-GAAP and ScoliScore which slightly impacted margins in that business in Q3. We continue to look for GM to widen with growing revenues in Pharmacogenomics, an increase in contribution from the higher margin bionconsumables (as opposed to instruments) from the Diagnostics/Tools business and potentially (depending on reimbursement) very beefy margins from ScoliScore as well as C-GAAP.
Net Income / EPS
EPS and net income were ($0.04) and ($2.9) million compared to our ($0.02) and ($1.2) million estimates. The miss coming from both a softer top-line as well as SG&A materially higher ($5.6 million A vs. $5.2 million E). At least a portion of the relatively high SG&A was additions to the sales force for ScoliScore (as well as C-GAAP). TBIO also took a slightly higher bad debt charge in the quarter. SG&A expense was 71% of revenue in Q3 - we expect this to moderate significantly in Q4 and we continue to look for this to come down closer to 50% over the next several years as revenue grows.
Transgenomic exited Q3 with $8.8 million in cash and liquid investments, compared to $15.3 million at the end of Q2. The $6.5 million reduction in cash balance included $2.6 million used in operating activities and $3.9 million related to the ScoliScore acquisition.
The remaining $5.5 million of the PGx Health note is carried as a current liability. TBIO has noted in their 10-Q's over the past several quarters that "We have contacted PGx on numerous occasions to make arrangements for the prepayment to PGx in accordance with the terms of the Note, as well as to coordinate the timing of the prepayment. However, PGx has not responded to any of our outreach efforts. We made our initial payment of $1.2 million under the Note in June 2012, and intend to continue to comply with the original terms of the Note. "
OUR 2013 OUTLOOK
We've again made some slight tweaks to our model. We model 2013 revenue of $40.0 million, implying growth of 20% from 2012. We look for Laboratory Services and Instruments to generate revenue of $25.6 million (+27%) and $14.5 million (+10%), respectively. We think net income and EPS come in at ($5.3) million and ($0.07).
We are maintaining our Outperform rating and $2.50/share price target on TBIO.
Our $25.6 million revenue estimate for Laboratory Services assumes meaningful contribution from new products in the clinical lab segment, including the C-GAAP Plavix response, atrial fibrillation, ScoliScore, and nuclear mitome tests. Very early indications are that there is real interest in TBIO's C-GAAP test. TBIO began adding headcount to promote C-GAAP earlier in 2012 and, with Medicare coverage now in place, expects the roll-out to gain even more momentum going into 2013. Management also has high expectations for ScoliScore. While reimbursement is currently somewhat spotty and payer specific, this could improve over time and with increased awareness. TBIO has already added headcount to help support their sales and marketing efforts of ScoliScore and thinks, depending on the level and prevalence of reimbursement, that they could break even on the $4.4 million purchase price in relatively short order. We model just over $2 million in ScoliScore revenue in 2013 - which, based on management's expectations could end up being highly conservative. In fact we estimate $2 million is about flat from the level of sales ScoliScore was generating prior to TBIO's acquisition - and we expect TBIO will be putting significantly more effort and resources behind sales/marketing of the test than did the predecessor. We will adjust our modeled sales of ScoliScore if and when it's reasonable to do so.
As noted, Pharmacogenomics revenue has been somewhat lackluster recently, but will hopefully rebound with the initiation of work on one or more phase III clinical trials which management has alluded to. Clearly there's real and growing interest in ICE COLD PCR which is further reinforced by the ongoing and recent collaborations with elite medical institutions. Management continues to indicate that there is substantial interest in their technology from some prominent names in pharma and they continue to score more and more clinical trials business. This remains the impetus to our expectations of significant growth in pharmacogenomics revenue over the longer term. And, as noted, due to its scalability, as this business grows TBIO's overall gross margins and profitability should accelerate at an even faster pace.
We model the equipment portion of Transgenomic's instrument business to grow in the low single digits in 2013 largely as a result of the recent roll-out of WAVE MCE to Menarini. Meanwhile we look for the consumables portion of the diagnostic tools business to turn in double digit growth in 2013, benefitting from the launch of several new ICE COLD PCR cancer kits (K-RAS, BRAF, EGFR, PIK3CA).
To access a free copy of the most recent TBIO research report, CLICK HERE.