Here it is, Fools -- the first quarter for
Mosaic (NYSE: MOS) since potash
hit the reset button. The company's fiscal-first-quarter
results were as bad as expected, with per-share earnings of
$0.23 approximating 2006 levels.
Do you remember anyone talking excitedly about fertilizer
stocks in 2006? Me neither. It wasn't until 2007 that the
fireworks startedfor companies like Mosaic and
PotashCorp (NYSE: POT).
Drilling down on the numbers, the company's phosphate
segment actually improved sequentially, and average selling
prices and volumes came in within guidance. Gross margins
improved to 14%, and management expects a "modest
improvement" in segment margins over the course of the fiscal
year.
It's hard to get too excited about the stabilizing
phosphate business when Mosaic's potash segment, in a
dirt-poor quarter, still generated 37% gross margins. Such a
diva, that potash -- always stealing the spotlight!
Underlining the stagnant nature of the global potash
market, China was actually a net exporter of the fertilizer
in July. The country is usually the top importer. No wonder
PotashCorp
cut its guidanceyet again last month.
Based on China's current inventories, however, it's only a
matter of months before the country will become active in the
potash market. Given the poor harvest this year, combined
with commodity price inflation risk spurred by an extremely
loose monetary policy, I don't expect China to drive too hard
a bargain when it returns to the table. China should be good
for at least 4 million metric tons of imports next year.
Droughts in India and Latin America, while no fun for
folks like agricultural products producer
Cresud (Nasdaq: CRESY), should also support a
return to more normal potash demand levels next year.
These phenomena appear well understood by investors,
judging by the lack of selling pressure yesterday on Mosaic
and other fertilizer shops like
Agrium (NYSE: AGU) and
CF Industries (NYSE: CF). Mosaic would
certainly catch my interest if it were to sink below $40 per
share, but for now, I don't see much of an investment
opportunity among the potash players.
Motley Fool CAPSplayers rate
Mosaicfour
stars, while
Agriumsports a full five. Weigh in on either stock with
your own outperform or underperform call.
This article was originally published as
Could This Be a Bottom in Fertilizer?on
Fool.com
Copyright 2009 The Motley Fool, LLC. All rights
reserved.
|