In recent months, publicly traded wine and spirits
companies in the U.S. have delivered
shot-glass-sized warningsabout the health of the industry
and the prospects for recovery.
On Thursday,
Diageo (NYSE: DEO), the world's biggest wine
and spirits company, delivered the chaser. Declaring
uncertainty about the "sustainability and pace of any
recovery," Diageo predicted low-single-digit growth in
operating earnings, excluding special items and currency
exchange, for the fiscal year that started July 1.
Comparing Diageo -- whose brands include Smirnoff vodka,
Captain Morgan rum, and Johnnie Walker whiskey -- to its
U.S-based peers can be tricky, and not just because
Diageo dwarfs themin market capitalization and geographic
reach. The U.S. companies report quarterly. London-based
Diageo reports every six months. Its preliminary fiscal-year
report, issued Thursday, covers all 12 months of its fiscal
year.
And while U.S. companies bemoaned the impact of a
strengthening U.S. dollar on their quarterly results, Diageo
rode the weakening of the British pound to a 15% gain in
reported sales year over year. Without the foreign-exchange
benefit and the gain from some new brands, Diageo's
fiscal-year revenue would have been flat.
The company announced two rounds of cost-cutting in
February and July, which should significantly reduce expenses
going forward.
Performance versus expectations
Major U.S.-traded wine and spirits companies showed a
consistent trend in their most recent quarterly reports.
Their
earnings per share beat analysts' estimates, but fell
below -- sometimes well below -- year-ago periods. The group
includes
Constellation Brands (NYSE: STZ),
Brown-Forman (NYSE: BF-B),
Central European Distribution (Nasdaq: CEDC),
and
Fortune Brands (NYSE: FO), a conglomerate of
spirits, golf equipment, and hardware.
Analysts had been optimistic about Diageo. Between early
May and Thursday, four investment-banking firms raised their
ratings.
However, Diageo's stock skidded Thursday after it unveiled
its results, even though the company's profit of 1.62 billion
pounds ($2.63 billion) beat last year's 1.52 billion pounds,
and edged the consensus forecast of analysts polled by
Bloomberg News.
I didn't see any analysts immediately running for cover
after Diageo's announcement. Maybe they appreciate a sobering
assessment by a wine and spirits company that still appears
to be the best-suited among peers to ride out the recession.
But if spirits aren't quite your tipple, you might be
interested in the increased prospects at big brewers such as
Molson Coors (NYSE: TAP) and
SABMiller (OTC BB: SBMRY.PK). Cheers!
Two fingers of further Foolishness:
begging to be bought.
It's also one of the
most efficient companies.
Rival Fortune Brands looks
poised to pop.
This article was originally published as
The Stock Market's Hangover Continueson
Fool.com
Copyright © 2009 The Motley Fool, LLC. All rights
reserved.
|