Last month,
Citigroup (NYSE: C)
drafted a planto get taxpayers out of its hair. Now one
of its biggest shareholders is calling for Uncle Sam to get
lost, too.
Saudi billionaire and big-time Citi shareholder Prince
Alwaleed bin Talal was recently quoted as saying, "The
earlier the U.S. government exits its investments in [banks],
the better ... We need to give confidence back to the
shareholders and investors that these companies are moving
along without government support."Â
Agreed. Now that taxpayers own common shares, there's no
reason to hang on other than gaining managerial control,
which regulators vow they have no intention of. Even for
banks taxpayers hold preferred stakes in, like
Bank of America (NYSE: BAC) and
Wells Fargo (NYSE: WFC), deep and liquid
markets for these securities have
roared back-- the government could sell them to private
investors without any material impact to the banks' balance
sheets.
To be fair, though, if we want to follow the prince's
advice and prove that Citigroup is "moving along without
government support," more has to be done than just selling
the government's equity stake.
For starters, Citigroup would have to back away from the
$306 billion
asset guaranteetaxpayers extended last fall. That would
shift a tremendous amount of risk back onto its own books,
increasing losses and dampening capital ratios.
It would also have to stop issuing debt backed by the
Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. Just last month, Citigroup
sold $5 billion of the stuff, which comes with an
artificially low cost of capital, being backed by taxpayers
and all. (In fairness,
General Electric (NYSE: GE) has been a big
fan of the subsidized debt, too.)
Citigroup would also have to stop selling asset-backed
securities into the Federal Reserve's TALF program -- a
subsidized mechanism for banks
to sell assetswhere there might not otherwise be private
demand.
So, sure, everyone wants to show the world these banks are
moving along without government support. Truth is, they're
not.
Careful what you wish for, Prince.
For related Foolishness:
Understanding Citigroup
With Lewis Gone, Is Pandit Next?
Citigroup Wants Taxpayers Out of Its Hair
This article was originally published as
Citigroup Wants Taxpayers Out of Its Hair: Round 2on
Fool.com
Copyright © 2009 The Motley Fool, LLC. All rights
reserved.
|