Many see China as the next great economic superpower. Yet
China could be facing a big problem: It appears to be going
down the same dangerous path the U.S. paved earlier this
decade.
Repeating the mistakes of others?
As the U.S. came out of the 2001 recession,
policymakers kept interest rates low for a long time to
ensure that the economic recovery was sustainable. However,
many now believe that low rates planted the seeds of the
housing bubble, which in turn created the financial crisis
we've struggled with for more than a year.
Similarly, this time around, China has instituted low
interest rates and lax lending policies in an effort to ward
off recession and return to torrid economic growth. That has
already led to concerns of what
The Wall Street Journalcalled a "speculative frenzy"
in Chinese assets. Already-expensive Chinese real estate has
continued to rise at a rapid rate, and the Shanghai composite
index has surged by more than 50% this year, outpacing the
S&P 500. Internet titan
Baidu (Nasdaq: BIDU) has tripled so far this
year, while other Chinese companies, such as insurer
China Life (NYSE: LFC) and oil giant
PetroChina (NYSE: PTR), have also posted
strong gains.
So is China for real?
Given the speed at which both real estate prices and
the stock market have surged, this raises the obvious
question: Is China's growth sustainable, or is an asset
bubble brewing?
Some have big concerns. "People don't focus enough on the
price of housing in Shanghai," said Simon Johnson, the former
chief economist of the International Monetary Fund who is now
a professor at MIT's Sloan School of Management
and a senior fellow at the Peterson Institute for
International Economics. "Seriously, I think the next wave of
bubbles is coming in emerging markets and is probably coming
in Asia."
That said, Johnson says Asia does have a good fundamental
story. "China's economic power is very real, though that's
not inconsistent with my view that the next big bubble is
coming in Asia." Johnson says every bubble starts with a
truly convincing shift in fundamentals.
Uri Landesman, head of global growth at
ING (NYSE: ING) Investment Management, told
me he thinks China's growth story will continue. "But I think
people have to realize that they did a tremendous amount of
raw-materials ordering in general industrial production in
the first half of the year and it may take some time for
consumption either domestically, or from their export
partners, to soak up all that production," Landesman
said.
Although China's economic growth could slow down somewhat
in the short term, as the country digests its heavy stimulus
spending and production ramp-up, Landesman says long-term
economic growth should continue humming.
Bob Doll, vice chairman and chief investment officer of
BlackRock (NYSE: BLK), agrees. "Economically,
China is doing OK," Doll says. "I don't think there's any
catastrophe in China. I think it's struggling as all emerging
markets do to get on a firmer footing."
Doll says that China was the first decent-sized market to
recover, and the fundamentals in China are much less skewed
than its stock market would portend.
Still, even sound fundamentals won't make Chinese stocks
immune to a future crisis. As Simon Johnson points out, "I'm
not saying that the next crisis is going to happen in six
months, or two years, or even three years. Emerging markets
often get into a five- to 10-year cycle. I'm just saying that
the way our financial markets operate, we tend to get carried
away with these speculative frenzies. The Internet bubble was
based on a reality. We have the Internet, and it really has
changed everything, but we got carried away." Continued... |