It's almost James Bond, Latin American style.
Regarding a lawsuit that
could possibly cost
Chevron (NYSE: CVX) $27 billion, video tapes
have been placed on the company's website (
here). Chevron
claims they indicate that Ecuadorean judge Juan Nunez, who
has been presiding over the civil trial in that country, has
determined Chevron's guilt and plans to rule in favor of the
plaintiffs.
The tapes were made secretly and without Chevron's
knowledge by Diego Borja, a contractor for Chevron, and Wayne
Hansen, an American businessman. The pair, who used cameras
hidden in a pen and a watch during meetings in Ecuador, were
apparently seeking clean-up contracts that might stem from
the suit. The suit relates to claims that Texaco severely
polluted the Amazon basin before that company was bought by
Chevron.
Borja and Hansen apparently met on several occasions with
the judge, or with a political party official, Patricio
Garcia, or both. Garcia allegedly was seeking $3 million in
bribes for delivering the contracts. During one meeting not
attended by the judge, Garcia reportedly informed Borja that
the money would be divided equally among the judge, the
"presidency," and plaintiffs in the lawsuit.
In response, the Ecuadorian government will investigate
the matter. They are requesting the unedited version of the
tapes from Chevron, while at the same time referring to the
translated Spanish as "misleading." At the same time, the
plaintiffs' attorney suing Chevron on behalf of the
indigenous Ecuadorians said the video "certainly looks like a
dirty trick."
I've watched the tapes, and they're well worth the time
spent. One meeting was summed up with the confirmation that a
decision would likely be rendered by the judge in October or
November and that the punitive amount "might be less, and it
might be more" than $27 billion. At that point, one of the
attendees chimed in, "Well, sell your shares in Chevron."
Doing business in Latin America is becoming more difficult
for Western oil companies. You are, of course, aware of
Hugo Chavez'snationalization of the industry in
Venezuela, which affected the likes of
ConocoPhillips (NYSE: COP),
BP (NYSE: BP), and
Total (NYSE: TOT).
And Brazil's president has now proposed
a series of measuresthat would increase
Petrobras ' (NYSE: PBR) influence over
activities in the country's deepwater pre-salt area. Those
proposals stopped
Royal Dutch Shell (NYSE: RDS-A) in its tracks
vis-a-vis new investments in the area.
So how should we treat Chevron now? The company stated on
Tuesday that it had no intention of paying $27 billion in
damages and has sent the tapes to the U.S. Justice
Department. My take, then, is that Chevron has benefited
dramatically by the release of these tapes and therefore, it
may not be wise to "sell your shares in Chevron" yet.
Chevron has been rated a four-star company (out of five
stars) by
Motley Fool CAPSplayers. Is your vote included in
that
assessment?
This article was originally published as
Big Oil Goes James Bond on Ecuadoron
Fool.com
Copyright © 2009 The Motley Fool, LLC. All rights
reserved.
|