Uncle Sam bailed out a slew of financial firms under its
Troubled Asset Relief Program a year ago -- but the CEOs of
these corporate welfare cases haven't exactly suffered since
then. As Congress begins to rumble about regulating bankers'
pay, a new report from the Institute for Policy Studies
chronicles the buoyant fortunes of these so-called "buyout
barons." Sorry, Ayn Rand fans, but we've got a serious
problem here. Many of these parasitic executives have twisted
the concept of healthy self-interest into a rampant, pathetic
sense of entitlement.
Cozy living under the TARP
According to the report, the top five
executive officers of the 20 U.S. financial firms that have
received the most bailout money received pay packages worth a
total of $3.2 billion in the three years through 2008. (Yes,
that includes years running up to when the bubble burst.)
Even in 2008, which we can all agree was a very bad year
for these companies, those CEOs still made 37% more than CEOs
elsewhere in the economy. The TARP bosses averaged $13.8
million, versus an average of $10.1 million for S&P 500
CEOs.
These individuals appear to face an even bigger payout in
2009. Arguably thanks to the government's intervention, many
of these the stocks for which these executives have received
options have recently soared. When even shares of
hollowed-out
Fannie Mae (NYSE: FNM) and
Freddie Mac (NYSE: FRE) have enjoyed a recent
rise for no good reason, higher stock prices are hardly a
measure of real success.
Unfortunately, these CEOs rewards for failure aren't
surprising.
AIG (NYSE: AIG) -- 80% owned by Uncle Sam --
has
doled out bonusesto executives for a job poorly done.
Meanwhile,
Bank of America (NYSE: BAC),
Citigroup (NYSE: C),
Goldman Sachs (NYSE: GS), and similar
companies' need for salvation from taxpayer funds via TARP
and other programs apparently hasn't led to many consequences
for top executives. Goldman might be on track to pay its
employees
the biggest bonus payoutsin its history.
It's some small consolation that top financial executives'
pay dropped by about one-third in 2008. Still, given the
government's monumental monetary interventions on their
companies' behalf, I'm amazed they're still getting that
much.
Moral hazard everywhere
I may have dubbed 2008
The Year of Moral Hazard, but it remains regrettably
rampant in 2009 as well. We're no closer to a better and more
reasonable view of the fundamental health of our corporations
or our economy. Indeed, we may have
institutionalized speculationinstead. Such policies seem
to reflect a growing sense of entitlement, not merit, in
corporate America.
When I recently looked at the
insane payawarded to
Abercrombie & Fitch 's (NYSE: ANF) CEO, I
realized that many people who'd battle unions tooth and nail
would likely defend these similarly senseless and entitled
pay policies for corporate top dogs. Like too many
unions, these executives reduce profitability, reward
suboptimal performance, and stubbornly defy the basic
economic need to excel and compete in order to survive.
Government policies, however well-intentioned, could
ultimately do similar damage. The White House might
potentially push the Fed to regulate bankers' pay to prevent
further such abuses. But the Fed may not be the best watchdog
here; many people feel it sided with bankers, not citizens,
during the worst of the financial crisis. And even before the
crash, the Fed blithely ignored -- if not outright encouraged
-- our economy's artificial growth during back-to-back asset
bubbles. Somehow, I doubt the Fed's intervention is the best
remedy for this mess -- at worst, it may further distort the
perverse incentives hindering our system, and increase the
resulting injustices.
The parasite economy
If we really want to fix the economy, we can start by
letting failed companies fail. Rather than looking to Uncle
Sam to impose some centralized fix, shareholders must also
start holding managements and boards
accountablefor how poorly their companies are run. If
these parasitic CEOs want to earn millions in compensation,
they need to do more than simply show up.
This article was originally published as
CEO Pay and the Parasite Economyon
Fool.com
Copyright © 2009 The Motley Fool, LLC. All rights
reserved.
|