In a commentary for the
Financial Times, Nouriel Roubini of New York
University recently warned that "the mother of all ... global
asset bubbles" may be under way, in which all risky assets
(stocks, high-yield bonds, oil, commodities, etc.) almost
everywhere have run
beyond what the fundamentals will bear. Roubini was early
(and lonely) in spotting the housing / credit bubble. What's
behind this new bubble, and how should investors respond?
Getting carried away
According to Roubini, investors are stoking a forest
fire with the "carry trade" as their kindling. This is how it
works: Investors borrow at a low interest rate in one
currency and invest in higher-yielding assets in a different
currency. If the exchange rate doesn't move against you, you
pocket (at minimum) the difference between the yield on the
assets and your borrowing cost.
Today, Roubini asserts, the U.S. dollar has become the
borrowing currency of choice for the carry trade because the
slide in the dollar compounds the Fed's zero interest rate
policy such that traders are effectively funding the carry
trade at negative interest rates. A negative borrowing cost
certainly lowers your hurdle rate -- is it any wonder that
all risk assets look attractive in that context?
A clue from Soros
The odor of the carry trade hasn't escaped George
Soros: At
The Economist's Buttonwood conference last month,
Soros -- who has been known to speculate on currencies --
noted that the short dollar trade is "extremely crowded." A
dollar-funded carry trade creates a short dollar position:
First, you borrow in dollars; then, in order to buy assets
that are denominated in another currency, you must sell your
dollars against the other currency, i.e., you end up short
dollars.
Saddled with pocketfuls of cheap dollars, investors have
gone on a shopping spree, scouring the globe for any asset
they expect to secrete a return above their borrowing cost.
For proof, UBS says its Global Equity Strategy Risk index,
which measures risk appetite,
reached its highest levelsince March 2000 on October
23rd. UBS's comprehensive index looks at investors'
preferences for higher-risk sectors and geographical regions,
along with equity option volatility and conditions in the
bond and currency markets. Historically, it has proven to be
an effective signal to move into lower-risk assets, even
below current levels.
A frenzied shopping spree
The results of this shopping spree are immediately
visible in the relative performance of emerging markets
versus the U.S. While the S&P 500 has delivered a
workmanlike effort since hitting its closing low on March 9,
rising 54.1%, that pales in comparison to more exotic
investment locales. The average return for the 22 emerging
markets tracked by MSCI over the same period is 90% in U.S.
dollar terms. A third of these markets have more than
doubled, including three of the four BRICs (Brazil, Russia,
India & China):
MSCI Country Index
% Return from March 9, 2009
(in USD, 11/02/2009)
Brazil
104.0%
China
78.2%
India
123.4%
Russia
117.5%
MSCI BRIC Index
97.6%
Within the BRICs, some individual stocks have
performed extraordinarily well:
Company
Country
% Return From March 9, 2009,
(I
n USD, at 11/02/2009)
Mechel OAO  (NYSE:
MTL)
Russia
450%
Vimpel-Communications (NYSE: VIP)
India
272%
Satyam Computer Services  (NYSE:
SAY) Continued... |